How STARCITY Checks Its Work
Verification log · Last updated November 21, 2026
STARCITY is built by one person with AI assistance. AI makes it fast to pull public data and add it up. It does not make the result right. This page shows how each paper was checked, what the checks found, and what was corrected, so you can judge the work for yourself and do the same in your own city.
The process
- Start from the original record. Every figure comes from a file a government agency publishes, downloaded on a stated date. Nothing is carried from memory or from a news summary.
- Publish the method and the script. Each paper says how its numbers were computed and what they leave out. The code is in the project's public repository, so anyone can run it again.
- Look for an official figure that should agree. Before trusting a number, find the same quantity measured by someone else, usually a state agency. If they differ, find out why, and print both.
- Look for independent reporting. Where newsrooms have covered the same records, check that the names and amounts match.
- Say what is not verified. If no outside figure exists, or a gap is unexplained, the paper says so.
- Correct in public. Mistakes are fixed in the paper and listed below with the date.
What the checks found
| Paper | Our figure | Outside figure | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Assessment equity | Price-related differential 1.037, median ratio 0.920, on 3,340 sales after values were set | State's 2026 Reports and Opinions: 1.006 and 0.970, on 8,360 earlier sales | Corrected. The paper first said the assessor failed the fairness test and did not mention the state's study. It now leads with both results and explains why they differ. |
| Property value | $44.4 billion assessed on the 2026 roll | State TIF report: $40.0 billion taxable in 2025, including TIF excess | Explained in part. Ours is a later year and includes exempt property. The size of the gap has not been measured, and the paper says so. |
| TIF districts | $1.295 billion of excess value in 89 active projects, 2024 | State reports: $1.377 billion for 2024, $1.506 billion for 2025 | Ours is lower by 6%. We count only projects the county marks active. The paper now calls its total a floor and points to the state's. |
| Home sales | Median price $320,000; $251 a square foot | Redfin: $315,000 for the three months ending October 2026; $166 a square foot | Price agrees within 2%. Price per square foot does not, because we divide by above-grade area only. The paper now warns against comparing it with listing sites. |
| Floodplain and flood loss | 275 claims, $2.63 million paid, 7 repeat-loss properties | None found | Not independently verified. These are direct counts from FEMA's files. No second official source publishes them for Lincoln. |
| Lincoln and the rest of the county | $53.44 billion assessed countywide; about $806,142,295 in estimated property tax | State: $47.16 billion taxable and $752.4 million levied for 2025 | Ours is higher by 13% and 7%. Later year, and exempt property is included. The gap has not been split between the two causes. Only 303 sales outside Lincoln, so that part is the least certain. |
| Votes and the ground they come from | Precinct vote shares by home value and housing age, 2012 to 2020 | 2025 city votes: precinct pages sum to the county's official totals (housing ordinance 30,913 to 15,311; council winners 27,819, 27,410 and 25,831). | 2025 matches. 2011 to 2019 use the county's own files and totals, with early votes outside the precincts. The 2012 to 2020 general election tables are still not compared with the certified canvass. |
| Campaign money | $1,068,502 in independent spending; largest funders of each group | News coverage of the 2023 mayor's race by the Flatwater Free Press and Nebraska Examiner | Names and direction agree. Totals were not checked line by line against individual filings. One candidate's committee was found to span two races, and a note was added. |
Corrections
| Date | Paper | What changed |
|---|---|---|
| November 21, 2026 | Assessment equity | Added the state's official 2026 ratio study beside our own and removed the statement that the assessor fails the fairness test. The PDF of this paper predates the change; the web page is current. |
| November 21, 2026 | Property value, TIF, Home sales, Floodplain | Added a section to each comparing its headline figure with an outside source, or saying none was found. |
| November 21, 2026 | All papers | Earlier releases described figures as citywide when the data had been clipped to the map's rectangle. Every paper was recomputed for the full city limits. |
| November 21, 2026 | Campaign money | Spending described only as "advertising" was first counted as TV and digital. It now has its own category. |
Why this is hard
- A number can be computed correctly and still mislead. Our assessment figure was right arithmetic. The error was not knowing the state already publishes the official measure.
- Public data has traps. Lincoln's city limits layer holds 70 shapes with the same name. Map layers report areas about 75% too large at this latitude. State files repeat records from year to year. Each produces a wrong answer that looks reasonable.
- Checking takes people who know the subject. A county assessor, a floodplain manager or a campaign treasurer can spot in a minute what a script never will.
What has not been done yet
- No paper has been reviewed by the agency whose data it uses, or by an outside expert.
- The figures on the map itself, outside the papers, have been checked less than the papers.
- Updates are still made by hand, so a figure can go stale without notice. Each one carries its date for that reason.
Check it yourself, or check your own city
- Pick one number from any paper and open the source listed at the bottom of that paper.
- Find the same number, or the rows it was added up from.
- If it does not match, report it on the project's issues page. It will be checked and, if wrong, corrected here with the date.
- To do this for another Nebraska city, the state's files for assessment, TIF and campaign finance cover every county and city in the same format. The scripts in the repository are a starting point.
See also where the city's data stops.
More at The STARCITY Papers and About.